“Catalina” by Karla Cornejo Villavicencio – A Review
⭐ Rating: 4/5
Year Published: 2024
Genre: Literary Fiction
Page Count: 224
Quick Summary
Catalina follows the titular character, Catalina Ituralde, an undocumented immigrant from Ecuador, through her final year at Harvard University. Raised in Queens by her grandparents after her parents' tragic death, Catalina navigates the elite academic environment while grappling with her undocumented status, complex family dynamics, and the looming uncertainty of her future.
What I Loved
Compelling Protagonist: Catalina's distinct and unique voice is both acerbic and gutsy. Her navigation of elite spaces, such as an Ivy League school and the publishing industry, while negotiating her identity and status as an undocumented "Dreamer" student, is portrayed with depth and authenticity.
Cultural Commentary: The novel insightfully depicts Catalina's experiences of racist microaggressions and the exoticization of her culture. Her perspective on learning about Ecuador through the privileged lens of her peers and professors, while being unable to visit due to her legal status, adds a poignant layer to her narrative.
Family Dynamics: The portrayal of Catalina's relationship with her grandparents juxtaposes societal perceptions of her as a "model migrant" against the authentic, human experiences of her family. Her grandfather's deportation struggles infuse the story with tension and highlight the precariousness of their situation.
What Didn’t Quite Work for Me
Meandering Narrative: The plot occasionally lacks focus, with a narrative that feels somewhat aimless. A more structured storyline could have enhanced the overall impact.
Who Should Read This?
This novel is ideal for readers interested in the immigrant experience in the United States, particularly those seeking to understand the challenges faced by undocumented young adults. It's also suitable for readers who appreciate character-driven narratives that delve into cultural identity, systemic inequities, and personal resilience.
Final Thoughts
Catalina offers a nuanced and intimate portrayal of an undocumented student's journey through the complexities of elite academia and personal identity. While the narrative structure may occasionally wander, the strength of Catalina's character and the exploration of timely themes make this a compelling and insightful read. I recommend it to anyone seeking a deeper understanding of the multifaceted immigrant experience in contemporary America.
