“Fall Into You” by Caroline Frank – A Review
⭐ Rating: 4/5
Year Published: 2021
Genre: Contemporary Romance
Page Count: 308
Quick Summary
Fall Into You is a sweet, laugh-out-loud romantic comedy about forbidden love, family expectations, and finding happiness after loss. Set against the nostalgic, autumnal backdrop of New York City, it follows a family-oriented heroine who finds herself falling—hard—for her brother’s best friend, a former ladies’ man trying to prove he’s changed. With relatable life transitions, meddling family drama, and undeniable chemistry, this book makes for a perfect cozy seasonal read.
What I Loved
A Surprisingly Charming Insta-Love Story: I don’t usually go for insta-love, but this book made it work, thanks to the emotional depth behind the romance and the history between the characters.
Brother’s Best Friend + Forbidden Love: The forbidden romance angle added tension and humor as the couple tried to keep their relationship a secret. The push-and-pull of family disapproval made their love story feel all the more rewarding.
A Hero Worth Rooting For: Matt, a recovering ladies’ man, was a genuinely sweet and swoon-worthy lead. His effort to prove himself and win over both the heroine and her family added layers to his character.
Relatable Family & Life Struggles: The book explores the challenges of navigating adulthood, loss, and family expectations, making it easy to connect with the characters.
A Cozy, Nostalgic NYC Setting: I hadn’t realized this book was set in New York City, but the setting brought back all my love for the city. The autumn vibes were perfectly balanced—not over the top, just enough to enhance the cozy feel.
What Didn’t Quite Work for Me
Insta-Love Is Still Insta-Love: While the romance was charming, it did require a little suspension of disbelief in how quickly the connection formed.
The Family Drama Was Frustrating at Times: While the heroine’s big Italian family added humor and depth, the overprotective brother angle felt a little heavy-handed at times.
Who Should Read This?
If you’re looking for a light, feel-good romance with a cozy fall setting, family drama, and a swoon-worthy brother’s best friend trope, Fall Into You is a great pick. Perfect for seasonal reading, especially if you love books that balance humor, heart, and romance.
Final Thoughts
While insta-love isn’t always my favorite, Fall Into You won me over with its heartfelt characters, relatable themes, and autumnal NYC charm. With a mix of forbidden romance, family meddling, and laugh-out-loud moments, this book delivers a fun, warmhearted love story that’s perfect for fall.
